Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility Nicholas Ephraim Young Docketed Letter: Cincinnati Stars Application

Lot #878
Nicholas Ephraim Young Docketed Letter: Cincinnati Stars Application to Join the National League (1879)

Estimate: $600+

The 30 Minute Rule begins December 9 at 7:00 PM EST. An Initial Bid Must Be Placed By December 9 at 6:00 PM EST To Participate After 6:00 PM EST

Server Time: 11/20/2026 07:45:10 AM EST
Sell a Similar Item?
Refer Collections and Get Paid
Share:  

Description

ALS signed “Chas. T. Blackburn, Secy. Cinti. Star B. B. Ass.,” one page, 8.5 x 11, September 23, 1879. Handwritten letter to "N. P. [sic] Young, Sec'y League Base Ball Ass.," early baseball executive Nicholas Ephraim Young, in full: "The Cinti. Star B. B. Association, in view of the probable retirement of the Cinti. B. B. Club from the League, hereby makes application, if said, vacancy should occur, for admission to said League Association, for the season of 1880. The required fee will be forwarded immediately upon notification." The embossed seal of the "Cincinnati Star B. B. Ass'n" is impressed at the lower right. Docketed on the reverse by Young: "Cincinnati Star B. B. A., Application for membership, Recd. Sept. 25, 1879." In very good condition, with edgewear and toning.

A charter member of the National League in its inaugural 1876 season, the Cincinnati Reds were present at the creation of major league baseball, though they struggled competitively and never emerged as contenders during their four-year NL tenure. Far more consequential was the club’s role in a defining clash between league authority and local economics. National League president William A. Hulbert’s rigid enforcement of morality policies—most notably prohibitions on Sunday games and the sale of beer—proved untenable in Cincinnati, where both were essential to financial survival. The conflict reached its conclusion following the 1879 season with the formal resignation of the Cincinnati Base Ball Association.

A replacement was quickly found in the Cincinnati Stars, whose September 1879 application to league secretary Nicholas Young is preserved in the present letter. The Stars were admitted for the 1880 season, playing their home games at Bank Street Grounds under manager John Clapp and featuring future Hall of Famer Deacon White. Their National League tenure proved equally brief: after finishing last with a 21–59 record, the club was dropped and replaced by the Detroit Wolverines for 1881.

Auction Info