Sold For $19,456
*Includes Buyers Premium
The opening of an autograph letter from Thomas Paine, unsigned, no date, penned on an off-white 7.25 x 2.25 sheet. The partial handwritten letter, addressed to William Duane, fiery editor of the Republican newspaper Aurora in Philadelphia, Paine offers a pointed yet respectful critique of a motion by “Mr. Morris” (Gouverneur Morris, a leading Federalist) to fortify New York City. The writing reads: “As the Aurora is become a center of information to the union, I send you some observations on a motion of Mr. Morris for fortifying New York; and as the writer of this respects the character of Mr. Morris, that gentleman will find nothing but the discipline of mild personality in these observations.” Matted and framed with a photo portrait and a print of the Thomas Paine Cottage to an overall size of 16.75 x 9.5; among the various annotations to the frame backing is a note indicating that the “Portion of Autograph Letter to Mr. Duane Regarding New York Harbor Defense” derives “From Wm. R. Langfeld Collection – Biographer of Washington Irving.” In fine condition. Accompanied by a full letter of authenticity from PSA.
Based on the political figures mentioned and the issues under debate, it stands to reason that this letter can be placed in the years 1801–1803, most likely around 1802, when Thomas Paine had returned to the United States and was actively sending political commentary to William Duane of the Aurora. During this period, the U.S. Senate—where Federalist Gouverneur Morris served as New York’s senator—was engaged in discussions about the inadequate state of New York Harbor’s defenses.
Within this context, Morris introduced a motion calling for additional fortification of New York, relating to federal funding or support for strengthening the harbor’s defensive works—a recurring Federalist priority between 1801 and 1803. These initiatives were part of an ongoing national effort to expand coastal fortifications that had begun in the 1790s and continued into the early 1800s.
Even after the Revolutionary War, New York remained vulnerable and strategically crucial, making continued fortification necessary. The city had been held by the British for much of the war, proving how easily a strong navy could seize it. With Britain still commanding the seas and tensions persisting over maritime rights, many feared a renewed conflict would again bring enemy ships to New York Harbor. Strengthening New York’s defenses was seen not as leftover wartime precaution but as an essential measure to protect the nation’s busiest port and its growing commercial lifeline.
Paine’s letter responds directly to this proposal. Writing to Duane—editor of the Republican Aurora—he offers “observations” on Morris’s motion for possible publication. While Paine notes his respect for Morris personally, he uses the opportunity to criticize what he viewed as unnecessary or excessive Federalist military expenditures. The letter fits neatly into the partisan debates of the early Jeffersonian era, when questions of fortifications, national defense, and federal spending were central political issues.
